Craft Fairs have, unfortunately, become all too synonymous with Grandma décor (a.k.a. doily-laced embroidered pillows with sappy sentiments like, “home is where is the heart is”). UGH – that calls for a big roll of the eyes! But it’s not just the quality of wares that have given Arts and Crafts Fairs a bad name – it’s the name itself.
Bazaar Bizarre's edgy graphics.
Let’s be honest, the word “Craft” is just a little too close to the word “Crap.”
In fact, when I recently signed-up to exhibit at my first Arts and Crafts Fair, I chose to deliberately advertise it as a “Holiday Art Fair” and very consciously left out the word “Craft” entirely. Frankly, the folks behind this show had some pretty shoddily put together marketing promotions (i.e. an outdated website and postcards designed with cliché, stock photo snowflakes, generic Times New Roman typeface, and poor typography). Needless to say, the marketing was bad enough without using a name that connoted more crap.
But the truth is, it’s just too easy a connection for folks not to make. A few days prior to the show, I received a joking encouragement email from a friend entitled, “The Arts & Crap Fair.” The message read: “Good luck at the Crap Fair. I’m sure your crap will be better than anybody else’s crap.”
And when the show was over, I received his follow-up email, “How would you rank your experience and sales on the Crappiness Rating Assessment Profile (CRAP), 1 being EXTREMELY SUCCESSFUL and 5 being REALLY IN THE TOILET?”
And just to kill the point to death, what do you think of when you hear “Arts and Crafts?” Personally, I’m reminded of Popsicle sticks, glitter, Elmer’s glue, and day camp. That’s great if you’re twelve – not so great if you’re trying to sell your quality, handcrafted wares to adults.
Although it’s pretty funny to mock, Craft Fairs are a serious business. In fact, the Holiday Craft Fair season is in full bloom. Last weekend there were more than two dozen shows just in the San Francisco Bay Area alone. That’s some pretty serious potential profits, especially if the fairs can attract more than just the grandma demographic (i.e. rebrand themselves to draw in a wider, more modern audience).
The good news is that crafters are starting to make some headway in separating themselves from the “crap.”
Etsy, a brilliant little website that provides small business entrepreneurs a way to buy and sell handmade items, branded their San Francisco Holiday Arts and Crafts Fair, “The Handmade Ho Down.” Although the name still reminds me a bit of square dancing and farmer’s overalls, it’s an improvement. Even better is their crafty, clever logo which uses DIY objects as letters (their letter “m” is made of Popsicle sticks, btw!) But it’s well executed– not at all grandma-ish.
Then there’s Bazaar Bizarre which literally uses the tagline,“not your granny’s craft fair!” With a skull and cross bone scissors imprinted embroidery-style on their craft book, Bazaar Bizarre’s edgier look and clever use of “knitting” the two demographics together is quite refreshing.
But the biggest revolution in the world of do-it-yourselfers isRenegade Craft Fair (a name that makes me think of combat boots rather than sewing machines). The word “renegade” literally means “to break with establish customs.” And that’sexactly what’s been missing: some smart marketing folks to turn the world of Craft Fairs on its head with a fresh name, awesome graphics (just the right combo of handmade, kitch, fun, and quality typography), and fabulous vendors. Renegade Craft Fair takes place annually in Brooklyn, Chicago, Los Angeles, and San Francisco (the SF show is this weekend Dec 19th and 20th). They attract 150-200 of the top crafters in the nation and 10,000-15,000 attendees. Now that’s some serious COOL.
So get those Popsicle sticks out of your ears and get thee to a Holiday (bleepin’) Fair, asap!
(originally appeared in SF Examiner 12/18/09)